According to a recent CNN survey, a solid 12% of Americans have “never heard of” Vice President Mike Pence.
Going by the video above, though, you’d think it was even more than that.
Following the survey, the Jimmy Kimmel Live team took to the streets to show random members of the public a photo a grinning Pence — and asked them to identify the man shown.
The results? Not so good.
“In a way I’m jealous of those people,” says Kimmel at the clip’s conclusion. “I really am.”
FORGET THE SUBSTANCE OF LAST NIGHT, because as you know, we are SOTU skeptics. But we have some observations from inside the chamber last night.
— THERE WAS DEFINITELY a weird vibe. It seemed a tad bit emptier than usual. Just two Democrats sat on the aisle to greet the president. Democrats chatted during parts of the speech. They barely stood, even when the president rattled off statistics about the growing economy that would’ve, in other years, had both sides on their feet.
— THE DEPLETED HOUSE REPUBLICAN MINORITY was on its feet frequently, chanting and cheering, hooting and hollering months after their 40-seat loss. They were especially inspired when the president said there could not be “ridiculous, partisan investigations” into his administration, perhaps forgetting that they investigated Barack Obama in ways that could be described in similar words.
— HMM? PRESIDENT DONALD TRUMP said he wants legal immigration in the “largest numbers ever.” Nevermind that Hill Republicans and his White House have dumped all over that, and have in fact called for cuts to legal immigration.
— IMMIGRATION POLITICS ARE GETTING WORSE. The president was booed when he mentioned a caravan coming to the U.S. Democrats laughed at Trump when he called the caravan an “onslaught.” He said: “I will never abolish our heroes from ICE.” Trump’s prepared remarks
TELLING: Democrats brought undocumented immigrants to the speech. Republicans brought people who had family members killed by immigrants.
— DEMOCRATS HAD SOME PEP IN THEIR STEP. Democrats cheered loudly when Trump talked about new jobs created during his administration — namely theirs, in Congress. They hollered when he talked about women in the workforce and in Congress. They were not applauding him — in fact they hardly did. They were applauding the fact that they were elected because of him.
… AT SOTU: Former Reps. Alan Grayson (D-Fla.), John Mica (R-Fla.), Jack Kingston (R-Ga.) and Darrell Issa (R-Calif.). Former Rep. Kevin Yoder (R-Kan.), who recently announced a new career in government affairs, sat in the back of the chamber next to Rep. Don Young (R-Alaska), the dean of the House. Former Rep. Michele Bachmann (R-Minn.) stood by the back door.
JUSTICES IN THE HOUSE: Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Neil Gorsuch, Elena Kagan and Brett Kavanaugh. Secretary of State Mike Pompeo shook hands with the justices.
Good Wednesday morning. AP … BREAKING: “NATO says Trump to meet other alliance leaders in London summit in December”
HOW IT PLAYED …
— BURGESS EVERETT, HEATHER CAYGLE and JOHN BRESNAHAN: “‘WTF’: Dems rip Trump speech as phony outreach”: “President Donald Trump urged bipartisanship during his State of the Union address Tuesday. Then he promptly called for Democrats to help him build a border wall, enact a new abortion ban and preemptively end the House’s investigations. Needless to say, it did not go over well.
“‘WTF,’ said Sen. Mazie Hirono (D-Hawaii) afterward about Trump’s immigration rhetoric. ‘Sickening,’ added Senate Minority Whip Dick Durbin (D-Ill). Rep. Emanuel Cleaver (D-Mo.) said he wasn’t sure Washington needs to even hold a State of the Union anymore. And Rep. Gerry Connolly (D-Va.) invoked Richard Nixon three times when discussing Trump’s speech.” POLITICO
NYT’S PETER BAKER on A1: “President Trump delivered a message of bipartisan unity on Tuesday night in his first address to Congress in the new era of divided government, but signaled that he will continue to wage war for the hard-line immigration policies that have polarized the capital and the nation.
“In a nationally televised speech that toggled between conciliation and confrontation, Mr. Trump presented himself as a leader who can work across party lines even as he pressed lawmakers to build a wall along the nation’s southwestern border that leaders of the newly empowered congressional Democrats have adamantly rejected.” NYT
L.A. TIMES’ JANET HOOK: “In his 1 hour, 22 minute speech to a joint session of Congress — one of the longest on record — Trump addressed two audiences and tried to accomplish two goals at odds with each other. Even as he exhorted members of Congress to come together on an agenda of shared legislative interests, he provoked Democrats on immigration, abortion and investigations of his administration.” LAT
TRUMP’S 2020 PREVIEW … via ANITA KUMAR: “In an 82-minute speech to Congress Tuesday, Trump boastfully claimed a long list of accomplishments likely to form the contours of his campaign to reclaim the White House: An economic turnaround. Trade agreements to help American workers. Criminal justice reform. Defeating the Islamic State and concluding ‘endless wars.’” POLITICO
WAPO’S BOB COSTA: “‘They know it’s his party’: Despite tensions with Trump, GOP lawmakers roar with approval for their president”: “Tuesday night’s State of the Union address, with thunderous applause and gushing accolades from Republicans, offered a reminder that, for all their policy differences and frustrations, the GOP is still very much the party of Trump.” WaPo
FROM 30,000 FEET — JOHN HARRIS: “Why Trump’s zig-zagging speech made perfect sense”: “President Donald Trump’s State of the Union address, as it unfolded, was a dizzying and even disorienting experience, a cascade of rhetorical passages that seemed to contradict each other every few moments.
“Appeals for unity and bipartisanship jostled with ideological and cultural scab-picking. Theatrics used by all modern presidents to swell the heart or moisten the eye — We are joined in the gallery tonight by… — were followed by the honking boasts of a MAGA rally.
“At first blush this all may have seemed like incoherence, as though the speech was a composite of recommendations from warring factions, every zig offset by a whiplashing zag. But taken as a whole, the address revealed a clear strategic purpose — one designed to revive and strengthen the ideological connection between the Trump of 2019 with the Trump who first began his astonishingly effective takeover of the Republican Party four years ago.” POLITICO
THE RESPONSE … “Stacey Abrams bashes Trump for shutdown ‘stunt’ in SOTU response,” by Daniel Strauss: “Democrat Stacey Abrams, the 2018 Democratic nominee for governor in Georgia, bashed President Donald Trump for the recent government shutdown as she delivered her party’s response to the State of the Union Tuesday night.
“In her rebuttal to Trump’s speech, Abrams shared her family’s history and her experiences as the state House minority leader in Georgia, and she strongly criticized the president for trying to gut Obamacare and warned about voter suppression in America.
“But she centered her most pointed criticism on the president’s role in the most recent government shutdown, saying that Trump made federal workers’ ‘livelihoods a pawn for political games.’” POLITICO
NEWS … HOUSE MINORITY WHIP STEVE SCALISE (R-LA.) will file a discharge petition to try to bring the Born Alive Survivors Protection Act to the House floor. The legislation aims to bar doctors from declining to care for a baby if it survives an abortion. The petition would have to reach 218 signatures to get to the floor.
THE INVESTIGATIONS … “Firms Recruited by Paul Manafort Are Investigated Over Foreign Payments,” by NYT’s Ken Vogel: “Federal prosecutors in recent weeks have been interviewing witnesses about the flow of foreign money to three powerful law and lobbying firms that Paul Manafort recruited seven years ago to help improve the image of the Russia-aligned president of Ukraine, people familiar with the questioning said.
“The previously unreported interviews about the flow of the money are among the latest developments in the investigation of key figures who worked at the three firms — Mercury Public Affairs, the Podesta Group and Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom.” NYT
— “Democratic Donor Who Pivoted to Trump Draws Scrutiny in Inaugural Inquiry,” by NYT’s Ken Vogel, David Kirkpatrick and Maggie Haberman: “In the world of big-dollar political donors, Imaad Zuberi is notable less for the scale of his giving than for its baldly transactional nature. … Telling friends he needed to act quickly to balance out his political connections if he hoped to maintain access, he donated more than $1.1 million to committees associated with Mr. Trump and the Republican Party in the three months after the 2016 election. …
“In an interview, Mr. Zuberi said that his donations were ‘more of a networking thing,” intended mostly to help him meet people who could help with a New York real estate investment fund. ‘To open doors, I have to donate,’ he said. ‘It’s just a fact of life.’ He added, ‘Not only did it not yield any business, but it actually backfired,’ because of the attention he has received since his donation was cited in the subpoena.’” NYT
TV THIS MORNING — VP Mike Pence will speak to Jeff Glor for an interview on “CBS This Morning.”
TRUMP’S WEDNESDAY — The president will announce the next World Bank president at 1:30 p.m. in the Roosevelt Room. POLITICO has scooped it’s David Malpass. At 2:50 p.m., he is leaving the White House for the State Department, where he will deliver a speech to the ministers of the global coalition to defeat ISIS. Trump will host a dinner at 6:30 p.m. in the Blue Room with the host committee and pastors ahead of the National Prayer Breakfast.
THE LATEST ON NORTHAM — “‘It’s a mess’: Race and gender fault lines in Virginia cripple Democrats,” by Marc Caputo and Maggie Severns in Richmond: “Democrats couldn’t react fast enough to the racist photo in Virginia Gov. Ralph Northam’s old yearbook showing one man dressed as a Klansman and another in blackface.
“But a newly surfaced sexual assault allegation against the man who would replace Northam if he resigns — Justin Fairfax, the state’s African-American lieutenant governor and a rising star in the party — has left Democratic national figures and Virginia lawmakers at a loss for words.
“The back-to-back stunners in Richmond exposed fault lines in the Democratic Party coalition that were unimaginable just five days ago. And with the state’s political hierarchy in the balance, the stories triggered a potential collision of two powerful forces in Democratic politics — the battle to combat racism and the movement to stop sexual harassment.” POLITICO
— “‘This isn’t me’: Gov. Northam’s defiance caught advisers off guard,” by WaPo’s Gregory Schneider and Laura Vozzella in Richmond: “Over the past several days, he has even toyed with the idea of leaving the Democratic Party and governing as an independent — a sign of the degree that he is isolated from every political ally, from his state party and from the national party.” WaPo
HMM — “Trump’s travel to Mar-a-Lago alone probably cost taxpayers more than $64 million,” by WaPo’s Philip Bump: “On Tuesday, [the GAO] released a report looking only at Trump’s first four trips to Mar-a-Lago as president: on Feb. 3-6; Feb. 10-12; Feb. 17-20; and March 3-5, 2017. The total? Just under $14 million, for an average cost of $3.4 million per trip.
“That includes about $8.5 million spent by the Defense Department and $5 million by the Department of Homeland Security. It also includes about $60,000 paid directly to Mar-a-Lago itself, $24,000 of which was for lodging for Defense Department personnel and $36,000 for operational space used by DHS.” WaPo
WSJ’S KATHERINE CLARKE: “Trump’s Childhood Home in Queens—With Life Size Cutout—Up For Sale”: “In Queens, N.Y., sits a roughly 2,500-square-foot President Trump collectible: the modest, yellow Tudor-style home he lived in during his early years is coming on the market for $2.9 million. … In the corner of the living room looms a cardboard cutout of the president dressed in a suit and his trademark red tie. ‘In this bedroom, President Donald J. Trump was likely conceived, by his parents, Fred and Mary Trump,’ reads a sign in one of the bedrooms.
“At $2.9 million, the house is seeking a mighty premium over neighboring homes in the Jamaica Estates area. A comparably sized home across the street is asking $1.25 million, and another similarly sized home a block away sold for just over $640,000 in 2016, public records show.” With three pics,WSJ
— “John Cantlie, a British Journalist Held Hostage by ISIS, Is Believed to Be Still Alive,” by NYT’s Rukmini Callimachi in Hasaka, Syria, and David Kirkpatrick and Richard Pérez-Peña in London: “More than six years after he was abducted in Syria by jihadists, John Cantlie, a British journalist, is believed to be still alive, a British government official said on Tuesday. Mr. Cantlie has been seen in several propaganda videos made by the Islamic State, also known as ISIS or ISIL, but the last one was released more than two years ago.
“On Tuesday, Ben Wallace, Britain’s minister for security, told journalists at a Home Office briefing that Mr. Cantlie was thought to be alive, though he did not disclose how the government might have knowledge of his condition.” NYT
SPOTTED: Beto O’Rourke in NYC on Tuesday night across the street from the NY Athletic Club. Pic with Jonathan Seabolt … Nikki Haley on Tuesday night having dinner at Bluebird London Restaurant in Time Warner Center.
BIRTHDAY OF THE DAY: Amy Robach, co-anchor of ABC’s “20/20,” is 46. A trend she thinks deserves more attention: “Compassion. I don’t think we share enough of the heroic inspiring stories that are happening every day around the world. We’re oftentimes focused on what’s going wrong, and what or who to be afraid of, and I’d like to see more men and women highlighted who are making the world a better place. As journalists we can help create a bigger and better feeling of community and compassion.” Playbook Plus Q&A
BIRTHDAYS: Tom Brokaw is 79 … Jerry Seib, executive Washington editor at the WSJ, is 63 … Mike Lukach … Todd Abrajano, acting deputy director at U.S. Trade and Development Agency … Ronald Reagan was born 108 years ago in Tampico, Ill. … The Daily Beast’s Lloyd Grove … CBS News’ Fernando Suarez is 4-0 … Aoife McCarthy … Rebecca Cooper … WaPo national political correspondent Jenna Johnson … David Brown, executive producer for WNET’s “MetroFocus,” is 52 … C. Boyden Gray is 76 … POLITICO’s Connor Coleman … Chris Slevin, VP at Economic Innovation Group … Daniel Wessel, spokesperson and deputy Trump war room director at the DNC … Evan Wessel, deputy director of the National Conference of Democratic Mayors (h/ts Michael) … Rep. Bonnie Watson Coleman (D-N.J.) is 74 … Rep. Brendan Boyle (D-Pa.) is 42 (h/t John McCarthy) …
… Alexa Cassanos, VP of corporate comms at Viacom (h/t Deirdre Latour) … TheBeatDC’s Tiffany Cross (h/t Kurt Bardella) … Jacquie Bloom … Missayr Boker … Annie Burns, partner at GMMB (h/t Jon Haber) … Eric Weiner … Mike Soraghan … Richard Cohen is 78 … Jay Dardenne is 65 … Jessica Mulligan … RNC’s Sarah Wood … Ray Conger, a recent NYU Stern MBA grad … Clay Helton, who recently joined Kraft Heinz Government Affairs … Jeremy Bowen, BBC Middle East editor, is 59 … Justin Pope, VP and COS at Longwood University, is 44 … Scott Atran is 67 … Ken Lisaius, SVP of comms at BIO … Rob Johnson … Helaine Klasky, chief comms officer at SoundExchange (h/t Ben Chang) … Mike Schmuhl … Britt Grant … Richard Seifman … Peter Stolz is 37 … Uber’s Malcolm Glenn … Peter Lutrario is 63 … Tommy Brown … Patrick Urbanus … Doug Campbell … Ricky Feller (h/ts Teresa Vilmain)
When New Girl wrapped its successful seven-season run on FOX last year, it left behind a void for sunny, quirky, ensemble-driven comedy. Luckily, creator Elizabeth Meriwether has ensured that her brand of humor will live on through her new show, ABC’s Single Parents.
Now midway through its first season, it makes a great case not only for why it’s probably the best new network comedy of last year, but also why it’s the perfect replacement for New Girl.
Single Parents, as the title loudly suggests, follows five single parents who form a “grid” because their children attend the same school. They rely on each other for babysitting, carpooling, and playdates before eventually becoming great friends.
It’s got a great lineup of actors, including Saturday Night Live vet Taran Killam, Gossip Girl star Leighton Meester, and Everybody Loves Raymond’s Brad Garrett, with breakouts Kimrie Lewis and Jake Choi. It’s also one of those rare television shows where the kids aren’t, to put it plainly, annoying as hell.
Much like New Girl, Single Parents isn’t looking to be break new ground or be the flag-bearer of a social message. It knows what it is and establishes it right away: a breezy comedy providing a positive respite from a dreary new cycle. Both shows demand you suspend logic to some extent if you want to buy into the central premise. This is evidenced by their similarly formulaic and cheesy pilots.
In New Girl, Jessica Day (Zooey Deschanel) goes through a bad breakup and moves into a loft with three strange dudes. Even though they barely know her, these guys band together to help her face her ex at the end of the episode. In Single Parents, Will Cooper (Killam) is the new single father in school. To avoid all of the extra work he’s piling onto them, the other single parents force him to go on a date and then end up rescuing him from it with a forgettable rendition of a Moana song.
Image: FOX via getty images
Image: ABC via Getty Images
Even some character traits are passed along from one show to the other.
Will can be optimistic and overbearing at the same time, much like New Girl’s Jessica. Jake Johnson’s constantly exasperated persona Nick Miller has carried on to some extent in Meester’s Single Parents avatar Angie D’Amato. It shouldn’t come as a surprise that, much like Jessica and Nick, Will and Angie seem destined for a slow-build on-again, off-again relationship.
Image: FOX via getty images
Image: ABC via Getty Images
Fortunately, Single Parents is forging its own path outside of these similarities to its Meriwether predecessor. It’s got the added complication of the five central characters — Will, Angie, Douglas, Poppy, Miggy — figuring out how single-handedly raise a child while making sense of their own lives. The show prioritizes showing these struggles but does so comically, while wrapping up the plot in 20-minute episodes. It is a sitcom, after all.
The show works well because of the cast’s shared chemistry. They pull off a daunting task because if this was real life, it’s hard to imagine their characters would be friends in the first place. In many ways, that’s the primary challenge Single Parents faces. Each of the adult characters is wildly different from the other. Poppy Banks (Lewis) is a modern feminist mom who owns a library called “Winebrary”; Douglas Fogerty (Garrett) is a traditional and wealthy white man who literally lives on a golf course, married a young stripper (now dead), and fathered twins; Miggy (Choi) is just a clueless millennial who is somehow supposed to care for a newborn.
As the season progresses, however, the show is wading through these waters slowly. We see how Poppy and Douglas are navigating their perspectives while clearly falling for each other. Even the child actors begin to zero in on their very specific character eccentricities and add to the ensemble.
Single Parents’s goofball humor has managed to stand its ground. It’s an added bonus that Hannah Simone, who aced her performance as Cecelia Parikh on New Girl, also recurs here. The writing is quippy, the acting is fantastic and establishes Meester as a total sitcom queen, and there is a surprising amount of character development over just half a season.
Meriwether has offered up another good-hearted concept and runs well with it. Single Parents still has a long way to go to catch up with the comical pinnacle New Girl reached. But if ABC decides to continue with it, there’s a good chance we’ll see it happen.
Single Parents airs new episodes every Wednesday at 9.30 p.m. on ABC. All episodes are available to stream on Hulu.
Sources: Clippers and Sixers have agreed to trade Tobias Harris, Boban Marjanovic, Mike Scott for Landry Shamet, Wilson Chandler, Mike Muscala, 2020 first-rounder, 2021 unprotected 1st via Miami and two second rounders.
Adrian Wojnarowski @wojespn
The Sixers are budgeting to re-sign and keep a new Big 4, including free agents Tobias Harris and Jimmy Butler this summer, league sources tell ESPN. Philadelphia has long-term plans for Harris, Butler, Joel Embiid and Ben Simmons together.
Bleacher Report @BleacherReport
76ers new starting lineup:
PG – Ben Simmons
SG – JJ Redick
SF – Jimmy Butler
PF – Tobias Harris
C – Joel Embiid https://t.co/EGcToC0LhL
Magic Johnson whenever he sees someone else pull off a successful trade https://t.co/M3J0T7GF6N
Bill Simmons @BillSimmons
How the hell did the Clippers get two firsts, including that great 2021 Miami pick, for a non All-Star who was leaving in 3 months? The Jerry West/Clippers era is amazing.
Jay King @ByJayKing
It would be funny if Jimmy Butler doesn’t like playing with Tobias Harris and therefore decides to sign with the Clippers this summer, though.
That being said, what a freaking coup for the LA Clippers. Shamet can run the same plays Doc Rivers had for JJ, just like he did in Philly, and those first-round picks are fantastic assets. The path of the Miami 2021 pick is one of my favorite NBA subplots.
sreekar @sreekyshooter
If the Sixers beat the Raptors in the playoffs and the Clippers use the extra ammunition they just got to trade for AD and then convince Kawhi to sign with them summer, Philadelphia needs to replace the Rocky statue with an Elton Brand statue
The Sixers have invested a lot of assets into getting Jimmy Butler and Tobias Harris. Now they should be a force to be reckoned with in the East this year and beyond. Not only that, but expect other East contenders — like Toronto — will try to respond to this by 3pm Thursday.
Rachel Nichols @Rachel__Nichols
Wow is Tobias Harris a good fit for the Sixers.
Also seems relevant: the Clippers’ first-round pick this year is supposed to go to Boston…unless the Clippers don’t make the playoffs.
Brian Witt @Wittnessed
Have to wonder if the 76ers’ win at Golden State last week gave Philly the confidence to shove more chips in for this year.
Shahbaz Khan @ShahbazMKhan
Only the greatest league in the world could make 1 AM on a random Tuesday in February this exciting.
Rachel Nichols @Rachel__Nichols
Let’s be honest, no matter what LA turns around and does from here, the fact that they made sure to send Bobi and Tobi out together make it good with me https://t.co/ESH8DdD4kJ
Sources: Clippers and Sixers have agreed to trade Tobias Harris, Boban Marjanovic, Mike Scott for Landry Shamet, Wilson Chandler, Mike Muscala, 2020 first-rounder, 2021 unprotected 1st via Miami and two second rounders.
Adrian Wojnarowski @wojespn
The Sixers are budgeting to re-sign and keep a new Big 4, including free agents Tobias Harris and Jimmy Butler this summer, league sources tell ESPN. Philadelphia has long-term plans for Harris, Butler, Joel Embiid and Ben Simmons together.
Bleacher Report @BleacherReport
76ers new starting lineup:
PG – Ben Simmons
SG – JJ Redick
SF – Jimmy Butler
PF – Tobias Harris
C – Joel Embiid https://t.co/EGcToC0LhL
Magic Johnson whenever he sees someone else pull off a successful trade https://t.co/M3J0T7GF6N
Bill Simmons @BillSimmons
How the hell did the Clippers get two firsts, including that great 2021 Miami pick, for a non All-Star who was leaving in 3 months? The Jerry West/Clippers era is amazing.
Jay King @ByJayKing
It would be funny if Jimmy Butler doesn’t like playing with Tobias Harris and therefore decides to sign with the Clippers this summer, though.
That being said, what a freaking coup for the LA Clippers. Shamet can run the same plays Doc Rivers had for JJ, just like he did in Philly, and those first-round picks are fantastic assets. The path of the Miami 2021 pick is one of my favorite NBA subplots.
sreekar @sreekyshooter
If the Sixers beat the Raptors in the playoffs and the Clippers use the extra ammunition they just got to trade for AD and then convince Kawhi to sign with them summer, Philadelphia needs to replace the Rocky statue with an Elton Brand statue
The Sixers have invested a lot of assets into getting Jimmy Butler and Tobias Harris. Now they should be a force to be reckoned with in the East this year and beyond. Not only that, but expect other East contenders — like Toronto — will try to respond to this by 3pm Thursday.
Rachel Nichols @Rachel__Nichols
Wow is Tobias Harris a good fit for the Sixers.
Also seems relevant: the Clippers’ first-round pick this year is supposed to go to Boston…unless the Clippers don’t make the playoffs.
Brian Witt @Wittnessed
Have to wonder if the 76ers’ win at Golden State last week gave Philly the confidence to shove more chips in for this year.
Shahbaz Khan @ShahbazMKhan
Only the greatest league in the world could make 1 AM on a random Tuesday in February this exciting.
Rachel Nichols @Rachel__Nichols
Let’s be honest, no matter what LA turns around and does from here, the fact that they made sure to send Bobi and Tobi out together make it good with me https://t.co/ESH8DdD4kJ
As night fell on the bucolic northern Indian hamlet of Mahaban, Gopi Chand Yadav gathered blankets and a flashlight to spend the night sitting on a wooden platform in his field. His task: to use bamboo sticks to ward off stray cattle from intruding and eating a maturing mustard crop.
Like Yadav, many thousands of farmers stay awake to guard their farms over a cold winter or face losing their crops to the cattle – a double whammy for growers already reeling from a plunge in crop prices.
While stray cows ambling around towns and villages have always been a feature of life in rural India, farmers say their number has increased sharply in recent years to the extent that they have become a menace, and blame the policies of Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist government.
Protecting cows – considered sacred to Hindus – was one of the measures meant to shore up support in the heavily populated, Hindi-speaking belt across northern India that has been a heartland of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party’s (BJP). Instead, it is creating a backlash, even among Hindu farmers.
“We already had enough problems and now the government has created one more,” said octogenarian farmer Baburao Saini from Kakripur village, about 85km from the capital, New Delhi.
WATCH: India’s farmers frustrated by insufficient government help (2:06)
“For the first time, we’ve been forced to stay in the fields to protect our crops”.
More than 50 farmers Reuters spoke to in Mahaban and nine other villages in Uttar Pradesh state said they would think twice before voting for Modi’s BJP in the next general election, due by May.
The cattle issue and low farm prices are major reasons behind their disillusionment with a party that most say they voted for in the last election in 2014.
Modi swept Uttar Pradesh at that poll, winning 73 of 80 seats in India’s most populous state, with rural voters swayed by a promise of higher crop prices, and as Hindu farmers supported the BJP amid tensions with the minority Muslim community.
As Hindus, we treat cows as sacred but these unwarranted measures have upended the economics of farming
Deepak Chaudhary, farmer
Cow protection
Modi is trying hard to claw back support among India’s 263 million farmers and their many millions of dependents after the BJP lost power in December to the opposition Congress in three big northern states where agriculture is a mainstay.
Farmers keep cows to produce milk, cheese and butter, but to harm or kill a cow, especially for food, is considered taboo by most Hindus.
Most states in India have long outlawed cow slaughter, but after coming to power in 2014 the BJP ratcheted up its distaste for trade in cattle, launching a crackdown on unlicensed abattoirs in Uttar Pradesh and on cattle smuggling nationwide.
At the same time, a wave of attacks on trucks carrying cattle by Hindu vigilante groups has scared away traders, most of whom are Muslims, bringing to a halt the trade even in bullocks, which are not considered sacred. Rising sales of tractors and increasing mechanisation mean that more animals are redundant for use in farming.
The farmers Reuters spoke to said they revered cows as most devout Hindus would, but a sudden halt in the trade of cattle had hit the rural economy. In their view, the government should come up with more cow shelters and let cattle traders deal in other animals without fear of attack.
“The government has only enforced the laws by closing down unlicensed abattoirs and cracking down on cattle smuggling,” said BJP spokesman Gopal Krishna Agarwal, who added that he runs a cow shelter of 1,300 cattle. “We’re not trying to hurt either any community or the rural economy”.
Crop trampled
Fodder prices have gone up by more than a third in the past year and most farmers cannot afford to keep cows after they stop producing milk, said farmer Rajesh Pahalwan as he smoked a hookah pipe in the village of Manoharpur. Six farmers sitting with him mainly nodded in agreement.
In India, the world’s biggest milk producer, about 3 million cattle become unproductive every year. In the past, Hindu farmers would sell unproductive cows to Muslim traders and about 2 million of these would end up smuggled to Bangladesh for meat and leather. But that trade has now been throttled by the government crackdown, trade and industry officials say.
That has led to many unproductive cattle being abandoned, farmers said, but governments – both state and federal – have failed to construct new shelters, leaving rising numbers of stray cattle that are feeding on crops, or even garbage.
“The government clearly did not think of alternatives before putting these curbs in place,” said farmer Deepak Chaudhary, who grows wheat on the outskirts of Mathura, considered to be the birthplace of the Hindu God Krishna.
“As Hindus, we treat cows as sacred but these unwarranted measures have upended the economics of farming”.
The government did provide some relief in its interim budget last week as it announced a cow welfare programme costing 7.50 billion rupees ($104.6m) in the year beginning April.
But there are hardly any “adequate measures to rehabilitate” cattle, said Fauzan Alvi, vice-president of the All India Meat and Livestock Exporters Association.
‘Investment went down the drain’
“Forget about cows, we cannot sell even a single animal to even our relatives thanks to cow vigilante groups which are aided and abetted by the BJP,” said the wheat farmer Chaudhary.
Modi has in the past condemned violence by cow vigilantes, but critics and opposition politicians say some of the right-wing Hindu groups involved have links to his party, a charge the BJP denies.
Nearly 85 percent of India’s farmers own less than 2 hectares (5 acres) of land, so even a relatively small area damaged has a big impact on their livelihood.
Only two weeks ago, some cattle ravaged an acre of wheat grown by farmer Chandra Pal in the Mathura district of Uttar Pradesh.
“My investment went down the drain after some stray cattle trampled and ate up the crop,” he said.
Many farmers in Uttar Pradesh are now using barbed wire to stop animals from entering their farms, but that is expensive.
“We have been at the receiving end of anti-farmer policies of the government and the problem of stray cattle is just another blow to us,” said farmer Amar Chand, from Maholi village who voted for Modi in 2014.
“Unlike the previous general election, farmers are not solidly behind Modi, who’s on shaky ground this time round.”
Yerevan, Armenia – Vahe Hovhannesian, a 31-year-old jeweller and Syrian refugee, sits by his work table in a studio in Yerevan.
An empty coffee cup, full ashtray, pliers, monocular glass loupe and weighing scale are scattered in front of him, along with a small pile of gold chains. His fingertips are stained black and he is sizing an engagement ring. In the corner of his cramped studio, a small portrait of Jesus hangs on the wall.
Outside, merchants barter and sell rings, bracelets, watches and other jewellery under the glare of fluorescent lights. It is a typical morning at World of Gold, a market in the Armenian capital.
Hovhannesian is one of tens of thousands of Christian Armenians who have returned in the wake of Syria’s civil war. Two years ago, he was living in Aleppo, dodging snipers on his way to work.
“Every day leaving my apartment, I knew that I could not turn right,” Hovhannesian said.
“I should always go to the left, otherwise I might be killed. There was a small territory in our district I had to cross to go to my workplace. I knew that there was a sniper and I was running so that he could not target me. Every day I had to run.”
Vahe Hovhannesian is one of more than 20,000 ethnic Armenians who returned to their homeland after fleeing Syria’s civil war [Dorian Geiger/Al Jazeera]
In early 2016, before Syrian President Bashar Al-Assad’s offensive on Aleppo, a rocket exploded in front of Hovhannesian’s house.
“The rocket fell right on our building,” he said. “It was useless to run or try to hide.”
The explosion nearly levelled their home.
“At that moment I realised that I had to leave Syria.”
Hovhannesian hired a taxi that drove him, his ageing parents, and his cat, Vito, to the Lebanese border. From there, they hitchhiked to Beirut, where they boarded a flight to Yerevan.
“We could take only our personal belongings and clothes. We left everything there, the apartment was fully furnished. We left the key to our neighbour.”
Ethnically Armenian, Hovhannesian is one of at least 22,000 Syrian-Armenian refugees who have travelled to the country since Syria’s conflict erupted in 2011.
Hovhannesian’s family’s journey, or return, has been in the making for over a century, beginning with the 1915 mass killings allegedly by Ottoman forces, which Armenians describe as genocide. Thousands were deported at the time.
For Christian Armenians, Aleppo became a sanctuary.
“Armenians have lived in Syria for centuries,” said Adam Pomiecinski, a professor of ethnology and anthropology at Poland’s Adam Mickiewicz University.
“A large diaspora was created after the Armenian genocide. The memory of this trauma is an important part of [their] cultural heritage.”
Markets like Yerevan’s World of Gold employ hundreds of Syrian Armenian jewellers [Dorian Geiger/Al Jazeera]
Armen Minassian of the Idea Foundation, an NGO that provides humanitarian assistance to refugees in Yerevan, said: “We know first-hand what it is to be a refugee.”
Syria’s acceptance of a Christian Armenian diaspora a century ago, Minassian said, is one of the driving factors behind contemporary Armenia’s willingness to resettle tens of thousands of Syrian-Armenians.
The Armenian government grants citizenship and employment rights to Syrian refugees who can prove their Armenian lineage.
Hovhannesian’s parents were naturalised after they presented documents showing they were members of the Armenian Apostolic Church.
“It was only natural to welcome refugees to Armenia from Syria, [and] not only to those of Armenian descent,” he explained.
Hovhannesian lives with his brother Zareh and parents, Andranik Hovhannesian and Vergin Khachaturyan in an apartment. His parents were living in southeast Turkey when violence unfolded in 1915.
They settled in Aleppo in 1946, where they found a home for 70 years. Hovhannesian’s father supported the family by frequently traveling to Libya for work.
Prior to the Syrian conflict, neither Vahe nor his parents had set foot in Armenia.
Arriving as a refugee was “numbing”, he said.
“My first days in Yerevan where quite difficult.”
The former Soviet Republic of Armenia is the poorest country in the South Caucus region, according to the International Monetary Fund [Dorian Geiger/Al Jazeera]
Adjusting to a lifestyle in a country that leans west politically, after surviving war in Syria, was jarring.
“Although I knew Armenian, I couldn’t understand when people were saying to me. They were using so many Russian words and expressions in their speech. I had never heard a single Russian word in my life before.”
A weak Armenian economy, lack of employment opportunities, low salaries, and high housing costs have made life challenging.
“They’ve had to start from zero, and obviously, they’ve had their difficulties,” said Hratch Tchilingirian, a sociologist and associate faculty member at the University of Oxford, who specialises in Middle Eastern and Armenian studies.
“The challenge that Syrian Armenians in Armenia face is economic,” he added.
Many have taken up trade work.
But the influx of so many Syrian-Armenians is perhaps most palpable in the service industry; dozens of restaurants offering Syrian culinary staples have popped up across the capital.
This is good news for Hovhannesian, too, who misses Syrian food.
“If we miss Syrian culture, we go to Syrian restaurants in Yerevan where we have the same food and music we had in Aleppo.”
Hovhannesian often works 12-hour days in the studio with Zareh, also a jeweller.
If life in Yerevan has felt alien, jewellery making has brought a sense of belonging.
“Jewellery is the profession of Armenians,” said Hovhannesian. “Our ancestors brought this culture with them when they were escaping from western Armenia.”
When he was 13, he dropped out of school. Hovhannesian’s uncle, a jeweller in Beirut, persuaded him to move to Lebanon where as a teenager, he first learned to work with precious stones and metals.
“I like this craft. If I try myself in any other sphere I wouldn’t reach this level of mastery.”
We’ve been jewellers and metallurgists since time eternal. Armenians are to jewellery, what the Swiss are for watches.
Pierre Akkelian, co-founder of the Armenian Jewelry Foundation
Hundreds, if not thousands, of ethnic Armenians who arrived from Syria, work as jewellers.
One floor above Hovhannesian’s studio, another Syrian Armenian, Vrezh Srapian, meticulously paints silver pomegranate pendants with acrylics.
Each piece fetches about 700 Armenian Dram ($1.50).
“I have to pay for our apartment rent, studio rent, and earn our living,” said Srapian, who left Syria in 2011. “Yesterday we left studio at 10:30 pm. It was early, sometimes we leave at 1am.”
Pierre Akkelian, co-founder of the Armenian Jewelry Foundation, said the craft was “part of Armenian DNA”.
Akkelian, who also grew up in Aleppo, settled in Montreal, Quebec, Canada in 1970.
“It goes back to the beginning of history. We’ve been jewellers and metallurgists since time eternal. Armenians are to jewellery, what the Swiss are for watches,” he said.
Since Syrian government forces recaptured Aleppo more than nearly two years ago, life has quietly resumed, but at a steep price – the Armenian diaspora there has been altered.
In the end, Syria’s civil war, which will enter its eighth year in March, forced an exodus of roughly 70,000 ethnic Armenians. Today, just 30,000 remain. Though a vast number returned to their homeland, tens of thousands of Syrian Armenians are now scattered throughout Lebanon, Canada, the US and Europe.
“Everything has changed,” said Hovhannesian, who has given up hope he’ll ever return to Syria. “People I knew are not there anymore. Nothing will be the same.”
After a rocket nearly levelled Hovhannesian’s home in Aleppo in 2016, he and his parents left Syria in search of a better life[Dorian Geiger/Al Jazeera]
With additional reporting by Arman Gharibyan in Yerevan: @armangharibyan
Athens, Greece – Turkey chose the day of the Greek prime minister’s visit to the country while placing a $6.1mn bounty for the capture of eight Turkish army officers seeking asylum in Greece.
Just days earlier, the National Security Council in Ankara issued a demand for their extradition despite Greece’s Supreme Court forbidding it on humanitarian grounds.
The court’s decision is unreviewable. But Turkey blames the men of helping to plot a failed coup against President Recep Tayyip Erdogan in July 2016 before commandeering a helicopter to flee to Greece.
To the conservative Greek opposition, Prime Minister Alexis Tsipras walked into a trap.
“This visit is poorly prepared by the Greek side, and augurs ill for Greek interests and Greek-Turkish relations,” said Greek shadow foreign minister Yiorgos Koumoutsakos.
In the last two years, Greece has registered record numbers of territorial and airspace violations by Turkey in the Aegean.
Territorial disputes to top agenda of Greece-Turkey talks
“For the last 18 months, Turkey has toughened its rhetoric and backed that up with actions,” said Angelos Syrigos, an expert in international law at Panteion University in Athens.
“The result is that the two countries are in a state of constant confrontation. Nothing has happened to make us believe in a breakthrough,” added Syrigos who is also a candidate with the conservative New Democracy party.
According to one retired Greek diplomat, Tsipras took the political cost of an embarrassing visit to Ankara to establish a line of communication with Erdogan amid worsening relations.
Erdogan’s visit to Athens 14 months ago remains a watershed moment in Greek-Turkish relations.
In addition to extradition of the officers, Erdogan demanded an amendment of the Lausanne Treaty of 1923.
The treaty not only delineated the Turkish state, it also normalises Greek-Turkish relations after a century of war. In Greek policy circles, it is considered untouchable. The call to revisit it suggested a broader revisionism of the Greek-Turkish status quo.
As a signatory to the International Law of the Sea, Greece claims the right to extend its territorial waters to 12 nautical miles (22.2 nautical km). It currently stands at half of that.
Because Greece owns thousands of islands, doing so would give it possession of almost three quarters of the Aegean. Turkey has threatened to go to war if that happens.
Last October, outgoing Greek Foreign Minister Nikos Kotzias announced imminent plans to move down this path by extending Greece’s territorial waters along its mainland coasts and Crete. The move left out the most contested area of Aegean islands. But the intent was clear.
“Our foreign policy… is addressing and implementing the expansion of our sovereign territory for the first time since the absorption of the Dodecanese islands,” said Kotzias, referring to Greece’s formal inclusion in 1948 of the last territory neighbouring Greece with a Greek population.
“The most important thing for Turkey is the Aegean,” said Kostas Yfantis, an international relations expert at Kadir Has and Panteion Universities.
“Although we in Greece say that Turkey is the revisionist actor in that relationship, Turks say it is Greece because the status quo of territorial waters in the Aegean is six nautical miles and Greece wants to expand to 12 nautical miles and change the status quo.”
Continental shelf
Greece and Turkey are also in a spat over delineation of their continental shelf, an area beyond territorial waters where states enjoy the right to exploit undersea resources.
Last October, Turkey sent a drilling ship to explore the seabed near Cyprus for oil and gas. This was in response to a similar exploration by the Cypriots.
A 1974 Turkish invasion of Cyprus after a Greek-inspired coup continues to divide the island and poison Greek-Turkish relations.
Hydrocarbons have deepened the disagreement. Turkey now also threatens to explore for hydrocarbons in areas Greece claims for its own continental shelf.
Syrigos believes hydrocarbons have been at the root of the disagreements all along.
“The potential for oil under the Aegean in the 1970s led Turkey to dispute the continental shelf of the Aegean and following that, almost all the entire legal regime of the Aegean,” said Syrigos.
The Great Population Exchange between Turkey and Greece – Al Jazeera World
“Right now it disputes whether the small islets not specifically named [in international treaties] belong to Greece, Greece’s airspace, Athens’ Flight Information Region, Greece’s Search and Rescue jurisdiction, the continental shelves established in the eastern Mediterranean.”
Such Turkish disputatiousness and Greek defiance nearly led to war in 1996, when Greece and Turkey sent warships and helicopters to the Imia islets in the east Aegean.
Three years later, massive earthquakes rocked Istanbul and Athens within months of each other. The two governments sent search-and-rescue teams to each other’s aid, and the atmosphere between them improved dramatically.
Kotzias was defiant in announcing Greece’s imminent expansion of territorial waters.
“In our view, the correct policy is not to say ‘we won’t extend our territorial waters because we’re in the middle of a negotiation with Turkey about the continental shelf’, nor to wait until that negotiation is over, because we’re then depriving ourselves of a right.”
In December 1999, Greece lifted its long-standing veto on Turkish membership talks with the European Union, and the two countries started exploratory talks that came close to resolving their territorial differences in the Aegean.
But Greece then hesitated to commit to any deal. Eighteen months ago, Turkey abandoned the talks altogether. Their relationship sweetened only to become bitter again.
Despite their need to re-establish a bilateral forum to discuss differences, expectations are kept to a low pitch.
USB drives are unfortunately small and easy to lose.
If you happened to misplace one on the southern tip of New Zealand’s South Island, scientists from the country’s National Institute of Water and Atmospheric Research (NIWA) are looking for you.
Just how they found it is rather interesting: The USB drive was found in the poop of a leopard seal, which had been sitting in a NIWA freezer since November 2017.
Three weeks ago, volunteers pulled out the sample for researchers to study, which starts by defrosting the poop.
“Then we basically have to sift it. You put it under the cold tap, get all the gross stuff off, smoosh it around a bit and separate the bones, feathers, seaweed and other stuff,” volunteer Jodie Warren said in a statement online.
Inside the poop, they found a USB drive which still worked. The drive contained photos of sea lions, and a video of someone kayaking, with a seal bobbing around in the background.
Looks like a great trip, by the way.
NIWA is searching for the owner of a USB stick found in the poo of a leopard seal… Recognise this video? Scientists analysing the scat of leopard seals have come across an unexpected discovery – a USB stick full of photos & still in working order! https://t.co/2SZVkm5az4pic.twitter.com/JLEC8vuHH0
So, NIWA is on the hunt for the owner, but what they actually want in exchange is more seal poo, which is valuable for researchers in their study of the animal.
“It is very worrying that these amazing Antarctic animals have plastic like this inside them,” Warren added. “The more we can find out about these creatures, the more we can ensure they are looked after.”