After Maximum Security was ruled the unofficial winner of the 145th running of the Kentucky Derby at Churchill Downs in Louisville, Kentucky, on Saturday, an objection led to a disqualification and rendered Country House the victor.
Maximum Security held off Country House to cross the finish line first, but it was determined that Maximum Security interfered with other horses—specifically War of Will—and a change was made:
At The Races @AtTheRaces
Wow! Result overturned! Following an objection after interference caused by Maximum Security, Country House is the @KentuckyDerby winner! #KyDerby https://t.co/XgeZrHZxgC
NBC Sports @NBCSports
An explanation of the historic inquiry ruling that disqualified Maximum Security, making Country House the @KentuckyDerby winner. https://t.co/YZqqn4ucbJ
Saturday marked the first time in Kentucky Derby history that a winner has been taken off the board due to an inquiry, and it benefited the Bill Mott-trained and Flavien Prat-ridden Country House:
NBC Sports @NBCSports
For the first time in the history of the #KYDerby, the horse that crossed the line first has been disqualified.
Here is the reaction after Country House was crowned the @KentuckyDerby winner. https://t.co/jmGO8Vm2iC
Here is the full order of finish following the controversial decision to take Maximum Security off the board, along with payouts for the top three finishers in 65-1 shot Country House, followed by Code of Honor and Tacitus:
Finish: Horse; Jockey; Trainer (Payout)
1 (DQ). Maximum Security; Luis Saez; Jason Servis
2. Country House; Flavien Prat; William I. Mott ($1.86 million)
3. Code of Honor; John R. Velazquez; Claude R. McGaughey III ($600,000)
4. Tacitus; Jose L. Ortiz; William I. Mott ($300,000)
5. Improbable; Irad Ortiz Jr.; Bob Baffert ($150,000)
6. Game Winner; Joel Rosario; Bob Baffert ($90,000)
7. Master Fencer; Julien R. Leparoux; Tsunoda K
8. War of Will; Tyler Gaffalione; Mark E. Casse
9. Plus Que Parfait; Ricardo Santana Jr.; Brendan P. Walsh
10. Win Win Win; Julian Pimentel; Michael J. Trombetta
11. Cutting Humor; Mike E. Smith; Todd A. Pletcher
12. By My Standards; Gabriel Saez; W. Bret Calhoun
13. Vekoma; Javier Castellano; George Weaver
14. Bodexpress; Chris Landeros; Gustavo Delgado
15. Tax; Junior Alvarado; Danny Gargan
16. Roadster; Florent Geroux; Bob Baffert
17. Long Range Toddy; Jon Kenton Court; Steven M. Asmussen
18. Spinoff; Manuel Franco; Todd A. Pletcher
19. Gray Magician; Drayden Van Dyke; Peter Miller
Kentucky Derby Betting Payouts (Win, Place, Show)
Country House ($132.40, $56.60, $24.60)
Code of Honor (N/A, $15.20, $9.80)
Tacitus (N/A, N/A, $5.60)
Exacta (20-13): $3,009.60
Trifecta (20-13-8): $5,737.65
Superfecta (20-13-8-5): $51,400.10
B/R Betting provided the following look at how Maximum Security bettors reacted when it was announced that he had been disqualified:
B/R Betting @br_betting
The scene at Churchill Downs when Maximum Security was disqualified
Unreal. https://t.co/bNnm2u4DlR
There were differing views on the decision to disqualify Maximum Security, especially since his move off the rail didn’t appear to impact Country House much.
WFAN’s Brian Monzo felt that Maximum Security proving to be the better horse down the stretch should have come into play:
Brian Monzo @BMonzoRadio
Country House did have the entire stretch to pass him, and he didn’t. Has to be considered.
Indianapolis Colts owner Jim Irsay also disagreed with the decision:
Jim Irsay @JimIrsay
The Derby. WOW. Maximum Security was robbed!
Former MLB catcher and current NYRA horse racing analyst Paul Lo Duca believed it was important to overturn the result in interest of fairness and consistency, however:
Paul Lo Duca @paulloduca16
Any other race Maximum Security gets taken down. We will see….
Even so, the decision was unprecedented, and it prevented Maximum Security trainer Jason Servis and jockey Luis Saez from their first Kentucky Derby wins, respectively.
While Mott was undoubtedly happy to win the Kentucky Derby for the first time in his illustrious career, he admitted that he would have preferred a clean finish:
The 2019 Kentucky Derby was thrown for a loop in the days leading up to the event this week when Omaha Beach was scratched due to an entrapped epiglottis. The Richard Mandella-trained horse had been the favorite and the top candidate to beat out Bob Baffert’s triumvirate of superstar horses in Game Winner, Roadster and Improbable.
Omaha Beach beat Improbable and Game Winner in the Arkansas Derby and Rebel Stakes, respectively, which made for a great potential storyline with Mandella looking for his first Triple Crown race win and Baffert looking for his 16th.
With Omaha Beach having to bow out, the door was open for a different horse to steal the headlines, and that is precisely what happened.
By virtue of Country House’s win, Baffert fell short of tying Ben Jones for the most Kentucky Derby wins of all time with six.
Baffert also won’t have the opportunity this year to become the first trainer in history to win the Triple Crown three times. Instead, Mott will go for his first Triple Crown and the first non-Baffert Triple Crown in horse racing since Laz Barrera won it behind Affirmed in 1978.
There have been two Triple Crown winners in the past four years with Baffert leading American Pharoah in 2015 and then Justify last year. If Country House manages to seal the deal with wins in the Preakness Stakes and Belmont Stakes, it will mark the first back-to-back Triple Crown winners since Seattle Slew and Affirmed in 1977 and 1978.
It bears watching heading toward the Preakness whether all three of Baffert’s horses will remain in the mix—and if it is possible for Omaha Beach to return to action. Should that happen, the road to a Triple Crown will be that much tougher for Country House.